S’mores Ice Cream Sandwich

If you’ve ever been camping, enjoyed an al fresco dinner or been a child, you will know and love s’mores! This delicious recipe sandwiches marshmallows and chocolate between graham cookies and is cooked over the campfire. However, ice cream sandwiches are obviously not something you are going to cook!

Instead, this recipe takes inspiration from the classic s’mores recipe to pair chocolate frosting and marshmallow fluff with ice cream, and graham crackers. It’s like a refreshing summer version of the iconic campfire treat.

You can use any cookies you want, any flavor of frosting and any kind of ice cream and it can be fun to mix and match or let the kids decide when making their own. Maybe you’ll come up with a brand new favorite combination. To make these into an adult-friendly elegant treat, you can dip them halfway in melted chocolate after freezing and serve with a toasted s’mores martini or espresso martini!

Why You’ll Love the Recipe:

These ice cream sandwiches are really special. They’re not the run-of-the-mill plain vanilla and wafer kind, but instead boast the tasty allure of s’mores with chocolate, graham crackers and marshmallow crème!

How to Serve Them:

Enjoy these straight from the freezer.

Can You Make Them Ahead?

You can. Just leave them in the freezer until you want to serve them.

Storage Instructions:

The ice cream sandwiches can be individually wrapped in foil and then sealed in a Ziploc freezer bag for up to 3 months.

Variations and Substitutions:

Instead of graham crackers, you can use chocolate chip cookies or vanilla cookies. What about strawberry ice cream or another flavor like cookies and cream? You can mix and match the flavors to your heart’s content!

Ingredients:

• Ice cream
• Marshmallow crème (marshmallow fluff)
• Chocolate frosting
• Graham cracker sheets

How to make S’mores Ice Cream Sandwich:

Step 1. Break the graham cracker sheets up so you end up with 24 squares.

Step 2. Spread a tablespoons of chocolate frosting on 12 of the squares and spread a tablespoon of marshmallow crème on the other 12 squares.

Step 2. Cut the cardboard off the ice cream with scissors so you just have the solid block of ice cream.

Step 4. Cut the ice cream lengthwise into thirds, and then you can cut every third into 2 squares.

Step 5. Now put each square of ice cream on a frosted graham cracker and top each one with the marshmallow crème graham cracker, marshmallow side down, to make the ice cream sandwiches.

Step 6. If you need to trim the ice cream edges to make them fit the crackers, you can eat them!

Step 7. Freeze for 4 hours or until completely set.

Step 8. Wrap each one in foil and put in a Ziploc freezer bag (you might want to double bag, just in case).

Treat yourself to a s’mores ice cream sandwich recipe and you’ll be so glad you did. The flavors in these sweet treats are truly wonderful and it’ll be hard to resist that second one!

Print